Stephen A. Smith blasts Aaron Rodgers as a toxic influence and warns Steelers to keep him away from Shedeur Sanders

With the 2025 NFL Draft just days away, speculation is heating up around the Pittsburgh Steelers ’ quarterback situation. Currently holding the 21st overall pick and lacking a clear starter, the team has been linked to both veteran free agent Aaron Rodgers and Colorado standout Shedeur Sanders . While the idea of pairing Rodgers with a rookie QB has excited some fans, ESPN’s Stephen A. Smith sees major red flags.

Stephen A. Smith says Aaron Rodgers' personal baggage makes him a poor mentor for a rookie
During a recent episode of First Take, Smith expressed serious concern over the idea of Rodgers serving as a mentor figure, particularly for a young quarterback like Shedeur Sanders. “Nobody is questioning the credentials, the acumen, the cerebral brilliance of an Aaron Rodgers. You’re questioning the willingness,” Smith said, emphasizing that mentorship involves more than just talent. He went further, saying, “When you are acknowledging and admitting you’ve got personal issues… That’s not somebody I want my young quarterback exposed to.”


Smith's statement reflects a growing unease among critics who question Rodgers' commitment and emotional stability. Known for his often mercurial nature, Rodgers has been public about his mental and spiritual explorations, raising eyebrows about his current mindset and reliability in a high-stakes environment like Pittsburgh.

Mike Tannenbaum believes Aaron Rodgers could add lasting value as a mentor

However, not everyone agrees with Smith. Former NFL executive Mike Tannenbaum countered by highlighting Rodgers’ positive impact on Jordan Love during their time with the Green Bay Packers. “I think Rodgers knows that part of his legacy will be what he can teach and be a role model to Shedeur, and that will last long after his playing days,” Tannenbaum explained. He argued that even indirect mentorship—how Rodgers carries himself behind the scenes—could provide valuable lessons for Sanders.

Shedeur Sanders’ draft stock has dipped slightly in recent weeks, but it's still unclear if he'll be available when the Steelers make their pick. Meanwhile, Rodgers' situation remains equally uncertain. He’s stated he’s “open to anything and attached to nothing,” signaling a willingness to retire if the right opportunity doesn’t present itself.

Also Read: Steelers choose mediocrity over greatness as Mike Tomlin eyes Kirk Cousins, not Aaron Rodgers

Whether the Steelers pursue Rodgers, draft Sanders, or somehow land both, the decision will shape the franchise’s future. But if Stephen A. Smith is right, pairing the two could be more volatile than visionary.